COLEMAN PUBLISHING • PART OF BROKEN PROMISES HEALTHCARE • ← Broken Promises Healthcare
Latest Investigation

The $100 Supplement Question

Prevagen, Balance of Nature, AG1, Tru Niagen and Mitopure: what does the science actually support?

Read the investigation →
A three-book investigation

What does your supplement label really tell you?

The American Supplement Investigation follows the money, the science, and the evidence behind the supplement aisle, with plain-language research you can check for yourself.

📄 New here? Download the free Reader's Guide (PDF) →

New · SuppleFacts App

Take the evidence with you.

Scan a bottle in the store aisle, see the real NIH label, and check each ingredient before you buy.

Get the app →
QR code for the SuppleFacts appOn a computer? Scan with your phone.
SuppleFacts app home screen: Before You Take It, Check the Evidence

Check a bottle in three steps

SuppleFacts connects what the label says to what the evidence says. Nothing to download from an app store.

1

Scan or search

Point your phone at the barcode, say the name, or type it. No barcode needed.

2

See the real label

Every ingredient and amount from the NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database.

3

Check the evidence

A plain-language AI summary, then a research prompt for the AI app you choose.

On a computer

Look up a supplement on the web

Search thousands of real supplement labels and find out what's actually in the product you're considering, then explore the clinical evidence, studied doses, safety concerns, and drug interactions.

Powered by supplement-label data from the NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database. How this works →

Try a search:

Go deeper

The investigation, the research library, and the web version of Product Lookup.

The Investigation

Three illustrated books

The science, the regulation, and the marketing behind the supplement aisle.

Read the books →
Evidence Library

Research guides and the Top 25

Sales versus science for America's best-selling supplements.

Explore the Top 25 →
On the web

Product Lookup

Search NIH label data from a computer, with the same research hand-off.

Look up a product →
America's 25 Most Popular Supplements

How Good Is the Evidence?

Explore summaries of the evidence, typical doses used in studies, and key safety considerations.

Explore All 25 →
Cover of What the Label Doesn't Tell You — Book One Cover of The Hollow Aisle — Book Two Cover of Prove It — Book Three
The Trilogy

The Investigation Behind the Website

Follow the Money. Follow the Science. Follow the Evidence.

The American Supplement Investigation examines how a $60+ billion industry grew, what the clinical evidence actually shows, how products are regulated, and what could change.

Read the Books — Free →
Systematic Reviews Clinical Trials Regulatory Reports Safety Studies Industry Documents
Explore the Research Library

Want to See the Evidence Yourself?

Hundreds of systematic reviews, randomized clinical trials, government reports, regulatory documents, and other primary sources — organized and annotated so you can examine the evidence yourself.

Browse the Evidence Library →

Includes:

  • Systematic reviews & meta-analyses
  • Randomized clinical trials
  • Government & regulatory reports
  • Industry documents
  • Annotated summaries
  • Links to original sources
🛡️

Independent and Unbiased

No paid sponsorships or industry advertising on this site.

🔬

Evidence-Based

Focus on high-quality research and authoritative sources.

🌿

Consumer Focused

Clear, practical information to help you make informed decisions.

📄

Free and Accessible

All resources are free for patients, clinicians, and the public.

Browse by Subject

Explore the Research Library

This investigation isn't one book — it's a growing body of evidence on how the supplement industry works, what the science actually shows, and what's at risk when neither is disclosed.

Free · Start Here

The Supplement Primer

A short, illustrated, plain-English guide to dietary supplements: how to read a label, judge a health claim, and ask five questions before you buy. Free when you subscribe.

Get the free primer →
New · Major Investigation

The $100 Supplement Question

Prevagen, Balance of Nature, AG1, Tru Niagen, and Timeline Mitopure: what each costs, what each promises, what the court records and clinical trials actually show.

Read the investigation →
Every Claim, Documented

Annotated Bibliography

Every GAO report, peer-reviewed trial, and federal source behind the numbers on this site — linked, verified, and organized by topic.

Browse the sources →
Evidence & Claims

How to Read a Health Claim

The Evidence Pyramid, the difference between a mechanism and a result, and why "clinically studied" can mean almost anything.

Read the research guide →
Regulation

The Regulatory Gap

Why a supplement can reach a shelf with no premarket proof of safety or effectiveness — and what the label is and isn't required to say.

Read the research guide →
Risk & Interactions

When Natural Isn't Safe

Documented liver injury, drug interactions, and dose toxicity — the evidence on real, measurable supplement harm.

Read the research guide →
Product Testing

Heavy Metals in Protein Powder

Why Consumer Reports, the Clean Label Project, and a peer-reviewed European study don't agree — and what actually changes if you use protein powder daily.

Read the research guide →
The Business

Who Profits From Belief

Subscription models, affiliate commissions, multi-level marketing, and the vocabulary built to sell science it doesn't have.

Read the research guide →
International Comparison

What Other Countries Do

Canada's licensing model, Australia's tiered evidence system — the working alternatives to the U.S. approach.

Read the research guide →
Market vs. Evidence

The Top 25 Supplements: Sales vs. Science

America's best-selling supplements, ranked, and rated against the actual clinical evidence behind each one.

Read the research guide →
Quick Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

The most common questions people ask about safety, interactions, evidence, regulation, and dosing — answered and sourced.

Read the FAQ →
Search Everything

Look Up a Supplement

Search across all three books, every research guide, the FAQ, and the full bibliography in one place.

Start searching →
Live NIH Data

Product Lookup

Look up any real supplement product's actual label — ingredients and claims — live from the NIH's own database.

Look up a product →
Phone App

SuppleFacts

The same NIH label data, built for your phone: scan a barcode or search by name, read the label, and check the evidence behind each ingredient.

Open SuppleFacts →
Free Tool

"What Are You Taking?"

A printable medication and supplement reconciliation worksheet — bring it to your next appointment.

Get the worksheet (PDF) →
Reader's Guide

How to Use This Site

A short PDF guide to Product Lookup and every other tool on this site — what each one does, and where to find it.

Download the guide (PDF) →
The Trilogy

The American Supplement Investigation

Why do millions of Americans spend billions of dollars on supplements whose benefits may be uncertain, whose claims can exceed the evidence, and whose risks are often poorly understood? A three-part investigation follows the evidence from the medicine cabinet to a recommendation for what should change.

Cover of What the Label Doesn't Tell You
Book One · The Promise and the Evidence

What the Label Doesn't Tell You

Evidence, anecdote, and the vitamin that reversed a generation of advice

A doctor recommended it. The biology made sense. Then the trial found the opposite. Built around the beta-carotene lung cancer trials of the 1990s, this volume teaches readers to tell a mechanism from a result, and a testimonial from proof — the toolkit for everything that follows.

Cover of The Hollow Aisle
Book Two · The Regulatory Gap, Risk, and the Business of Belief

The Hollow Aisle

What the law never required anyone to prove

A supplement can reach your shelf with no premarket safety or efficacy review. This volume follows the label, the marketplace, the documented harms, the dollar, and the vocabulary built to sell science it doesn't have — closing with a practical medication-and-supplement worksheet for your next appointment.

Cover of Prove It
Book Three · The Reckoning

Prove It

Chronic disease claims, misinformation, and what should change

The trilogy's final volume applies Books One and Two to real chronic disease claims, the information ecosystem that spreads them, and a set of documented case files — closing with a specific, evidence-based recommendation for what U.S. supplement regulation should actually look like.

Book Three · Closing Appendix

What Should Change

A tiered evidence framework modeled on Canada's and Australia's working supplement regulatory systems — not full drug-style approval, and not the status quo.

Read the appendix →
Why This Investigation

Why "The American Supplement Investigation"?

Nearly three in four American adults take a dietary supplement. Most assume — reasonably, given how similar the packaging looks to regulated medicine — that some level of government testing stands behind the claim on the label. In most cases, none does.

This is not an argument that supplements are fraudulent. Some work, for some people, for some purposes, and the evidence for a few is genuinely strong. It is an argument that the confidence with which a product is chosen and the evidence that actually exists for it are, far too often, two very different things.

"I write as an investigator, not an advocate. The most dangerous claims are rarely the obviously false ones. They're the ones that are technically true, biologically plausible, and still misleading."

Drawing on Robert Coleman's forty years in medicine — sixteen as Director of Clinical Pharmacy Services at the VA Palo Alto Health Care System — and the clinical pharmacy expertise of co-authors Joy Meier and Julio Lopez, this investigation applies the same evidence-based standard as Broken Promises Healthcare to a $60 billion industry most Americans engage with every single day.

How We Source Claims

Every Figure, Sourced

Every factual claim in this investigation is sourced — to peer-reviewed research, federal regulatory documents, or government data. Where a figure is an estimate or a range, we say so. If you believe a citation has been misrepresented, tell us — we want to know.

Robert W. Coleman, MS Pharm.

Robert W. Coleman, MS Pharm.

Forty years in medicine, sixteen of them as Director of Clinical Pharmacy Services at the VA Palo Alto Health Care System, where he ran medication safety programs for tens of thousands of veterans. His peer-reviewed research spans infectious disease, pharmacokinetics, anticoagulation therapy, and medical informatics. He writes as an investigator, not an advocate.

Joy Meier
Pharm.D.

Joy Meier, Pharm.D.

Bio placeholder — to be supplied by Joy. Suggested elements: clinical background and credentials, current or most recent practice setting, relevant specialization, and how she came to co-author this investigation.
Julio Lopez
Pharm.D.

Julio Lopez, Pharm.D.

Julio Lopez, Pharm.D., graduated from the University of California, San Francisco. After two years of residency, he worked for the VA health care system at its Martinez, California campus. He started as a drug information pharmacist and, for the last 20 years of his full-time career, served as Chief of Pharmacy for the Pharmacy Service. In addition to his regular job responsibilities, he has done research and has published in many pharmacy and medical journals. He is currently retired.

Get in Touch

Questions about the research, the trilogy, or reform collaboration — reach out directly.